@radix-ui/react-dialog vs Shadcn-ui

Downloads & Popularity

@radix-ui/react-dialog leads with 35.8M weekly downloads — roughly 274.6x more. Shadcn-ui has 130.5K weekly downloads. Higher download counts generally indicate broader community adoption and a larger ecosystem of tutorials, plugins, and support.

Bundle Size

Shadcn-ui has the smallest gzipped bundle at 2.5 KB. @radix-ui/react-dialog comes in at 10.6 KB. A smaller bundle size means faster page loads, which improves user experience and Core Web Vitals scores.

Health Score Comparison

@radix-ui/react-dialog has an overall health score of 73/100 (good), with strong security, popularity scores. Shadcn-ui has an overall health score of 63/100 (good), with strong security, popularity scores. Health scores are calculated from maintenance activity, code quality, security posture, popularity, and stability metrics.

When to Choose Each

Choose @radix-ui/react-dialog if you value massive community and ecosystem, strong security track record. Choose Shadcn-ui if you value minimal bundle footprint, strong security track record.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is @radix-ui/react-dialog better than shadcn-ui?

It depends on your needs. @radix-ui/react-dialog has a health score of 73/100 while Shadcn-ui scores 63/100. @radix-ui/react-dialog has more weekly downloads (35.8M), suggesting broader adoption. Consider your specific requirements — bundle size, community support, and feature set — to decide which is the better fit.

Which has a smaller bundle size, @radix-ui/react-dialog or shadcn-ui?

Shadcn-ui has the smaller gzipped bundle at 2.5 KB. A smaller bundle means faster load times for your users, which can positively impact SEO and user experience.

How many developers use @radix-ui/react-dialog vs shadcn-ui?

Based on npm download statistics, @radix-ui/react-dialog has approximately 35.8M weekly downloads and Shadcn-ui has approximately 130.5K weekly downloads. These numbers reflect package installations, not unique developers, but they indicate relative adoption levels.

Which is better maintained, @radix-ui/react-dialog or shadcn-ui?

@radix-ui/react-dialog currently has the higher overall health score at 73/100. @radix-ui/react-dialog has a maintenance score of 60/100 and Shadcn-ui scores 40/100 on maintenance.